Everyones P&L Screenshot Is Real. That's Still Not the Whole Story.
June 17, 2026 · ~6 min read · Updated September 4, 2026 · by Shivam Kushwaha, HeyArtha founder
You scroll through trading Twitter on your lunch break and every third post is someone's account turning a few thousand into a few lakhs overnight. Green numbers, confident captions, replies full of fire emojis. You close the app and open your own broker app, where the number is red, ordinary, unremarkable. You didn't do anything wrong today. It just doesn't feel that way anymore.
The math your feed is quietly hiding from you
Here's the mechanism worth understanding clearly: a trader who makes a large gain on a single trade will very likely post the screenshot. A trader who loses an equivalent amount almost never will. This isn't a minor bias — it's systematic. If you follow two hundred traders and each shares only their best trade of the month, your feed becomes a continuous stream of spectacular outcomes, with the losses, the blown accounts, and the average, boring Tuesday completely absent from what you see. The sample you're being shown isn't representative of what trading actually looks like. It's a highlight reel, curated by a selection bias nobody announces out loud.
Just how lopsided the real numbers are
It's worth grounding this in the actual data, because the gap between the feed and reality is larger than most people assume. SEBI's latest study found that about 88% of individual equity derivatives traders had net losses in FY26, down from about 91% in FY25, with aggregate net losses of about ₹91,685 crore. That means the large majority of individual futures and options traders — and plausibly plenty of the accounts posting green screenshots — end a year behind. The wins get posted. The overall picture, which is mostly red, doesn't.
Why this specific comparison hurts more than it should
Many traders find that a missed win stings more than an equivalent loss, and the pain of regret over a missed opportunity is one likely reason — the same asymmetry that makes a missed setup replay in your head long after a real loss has closed. Watching someone else's win on your screen can trigger something close to that same "missed opportunity" feeling, which is one reason trading social media feel feel so personally deflating even when nothing about your own trading has actually gotten worse.
What you're not seeing behind the screenshot
Beyond the simple selection bias of wins-over-losses, there's a second layer worth knowing: the specific trades that go viral tend to be outliers by design — the 200% winner, the perfect entry at the exact low, a small account turned into something dramatic overnight. Even among traders who do occasionally post real wins, these specific outlier trades are wildly unrepresentative of their own average results, let alone anyone else's. You're not just seeing a curated slice of other people's outcomes. You're seeing the most extreme slice of an already-curated slice, and comparing your entire ordinary week against it.
What actually helps with this specific comparison spiral
A common suggestion isn't complicated: reducing exposure to trading social media specifically during market hours, when a screenshot can actually trigger an impulsive chase. Checking it after the close, once you're no longer in a position to act on the urgency, removes most of the danger without requiring you to quit the communities entirely. Some traders also find it useful to deliberately track when comparison-driven trades happen in their own journal — noting the pattern of "saw someone else's win, felt behind, took a trade I wouldn't have otherwise" — since naming the pattern tends to weaken its pull the next time it shows up.
It also helps to remember, concretely, what you genuinely don't know about any screenshot you see: the account size behind the percentage gain, the risk actually taken to get there, how many losing trades came before it, a red stretch nobody screenshots the way they screenshot the win, or whether the account is even still funded by the time you're seeing the post. A win with no context isn't really information. It's just a feeling wearing the costume of information.
Where Artha fits into this
Saying "I saw someone's win today and it wrecked my whole afternoon" out loud, to someone who's had the exact same reaction to a screenshot that told them nothing real about their own trading, matters more than it sounds, the same kind of honesty that's easy to lose track of alone with a chart.
The number worth actually tracking
Your results aren't worse because everyone else is winning more than you. They're not worse at all, most likely — you're just being shown a version of everyone else that was never designed to be representative in the first place. The only P&L worth genuinely comparing yourself against is your own, from last month, not a stranger's biggest win of the year dressed up as their average one.
Quick answers
Things people usually want to know.
Why does my trading feed seem to show everyone winning except me?
Traders post winning trades far more often than losses, so your feed shows a curated slice of outcomes rather than average results. This is a selection effect, and it is why an ordinary week can feel like falling behind.
What percentage of retail traders actually lose money?
SEBI's study of individual equity derivatives traders found that about 88 percent had net losses in FY26, down from about 91 percent in FY25, with aggregate net losses of roughly ₹91,685 crore in FY26. Those figures cover futures and options traders, not all retail investors.
Why does seeing someone else's trading win feel worse than my own loss?
Many traders report that watching someone else's win feels like a missed chance, which can sting more than expected. That is a common reaction to comparison, though how strongly it hits varies from person to person.
Are the trades people post on social media representative of their actual results?
Usually not. Trades that go viral tend to be the highlights of someone's month or year, not their typical outcome, which makes the comparison doubly misleading. A screenshot shows one result, not the account's record.
How can I reduce the negative impact of trading social media on my mindset?
One approach is to limit exposure during market hours, when a screenshot could trigger an impulsive trade, and check social media after the close instead. Noting in your journal when a trade was comparison-driven can also help you spot the pattern.
Should I stop following trading accounts on social media entirely?
Not necessarily. Many traders find value in the peer discussion and information these accounts provide. Being deliberate about when you check them, and sceptical of what any single screenshot represents, matters more than quitting entirely.
What information is missing from a typical trading win screenshot?
Screenshots rarely show the account size behind a percentage gain, the risk taken to get there, the losing trades that came before it, or whether the account is still funded. Without that context, a win is a feeling rather than information about skill.
Do SEBI figures mean most profitable traders on social media are lying?
No. A screenshot can be genuine and still unrepresentative. SEBI's data shows that most individual derivatives traders lose money overall, so the traders who post are a small, self-selected group whose highlights reach you.
What is the right way to measure my own trading progress?
Compare yourself with your own record, such as last month's results, process quality and rule-following, not with a stranger's biggest win. A journal that records every trade, including the losing ones, gives you a fairer baseline than a feed.
More from HeyArtha
Other things we've been writing about.
Brokerage Charges and Tax on Trading Income in India (2026)
Brokerage is the smallest cost. What STT, GST, stamp duty and DP charges add to a ₹1 lakh delivery trade, and how delivery, intraday and F&O income is taxed.
Budget Day Brain: Why Feb 1 Turns Disciplined Traders Reckless
Union Budget day making your trading brain go haywire? Here's an honest look at the psychology of high-volatility event days, no calls, just the mindset.
What the CFA Charter Actually Gets You in India: A Realistic View
₹32.4 lakh average for recent charterholders, ₹66.6 lakh overall. Here's what those numbers actually mean, and what they don't.